Stages of Disciplinary Proceedings for Civil Servants of the Russian Federation

The paper examines the content and structure of law enforcement in connection with the commission of  disciplinary offenses by civil servants through the implementation of procedural norms of disciplinary proceedings  that represents one of the forms of enforcing social and, as a variety of them, law rules. The author characterises  such an independent element of the legal process as the stages of procedural hearings, shows the correlation for  differentiation between their content and the main stages of law enforcement. The author analizes approaches to  determining the stage of the legal and administrative procedure, highlights their features and proposes to apply  the results of the analysis to determining the stage of hearings in disciplinary cases. The author shows the points  of view of specialists on the system and types of the main and optional stages of proceedings in disciplinary cases  brought against civil servants, substantiates the criteria underlying the selection of a certain procedural stage,  their functional role in proceedings and draws a conclusion about the types of stages of proceedings in disciplinary  cases. The paper substantiates the opinion that the revision of a disciplinary case as a separate, independent stage,  not included in the structure of this proceeding, is possible through the resolution of a public service dispute.  In conclusion, the author characterises the existing procedure (model) of proceedings for the imposition of a  disciplinary sanction that can be simplified and ordinary (complete).

1. Administrativno-processual’noe pravo : uchebnik / pod red. d-ra yurid. nauk, prof. A. I. Kaplunova. — 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. / Izd-vo SPb. un-ta MVD Rossii. — SPb. : OOO «R-KOPI», 2017. — 376 s.

2. Adushkin Yu. S. Disciplinarnoe proizvodstvo v SSSR / pod red. V. M. Manohina. — Saratov : Izd-vo Sarat. un-ta, 1986. — 125 s.

3. Alekseev S. S. Sobranie sochinenij : v 10 t. T. 3 : Problemy teorii prava : kurs lekcij. — M. : Statut, 2010. — 781 s.

4. Bahrah D. N. Administrativnaya otvetstvennost’ grazhdan v SSSR: uchebnoe posobie. — Sverdlovsk, 1989. — 204 s.

5. Bahrah D. N. Administrativnoe pravo : uchebnik. — M. : Eksmo, 2011. — 624 s.

6. Gorshenev V. M. Sposoby i organizacionnye formy pravovogo regulirovaniya v socialisticheskom obshchestve. — M. : Yurid. lit., 1972. — 258 s.

7. Dobrobaba M. B. Disciplinarnaya otvetstvennost’ v sisteme gosudarstvenno-sluzhebnyh pravootnoshenij : dis. … d-ra yurid. nauk. — Saratov, 2018. — 463 s.

8. Kaplunov A. I., Rogozhkina E. A. O stadiyah proizvodstva po disciplinarnym delam v organah vnutrennih del s uchetom polozhenij teorii primeneniya norm administrativnogo prava, razrabotannyh Alekseem Prokof’evichem Korenevym // Aktual’nye problemy administrativnogo prava i processa. — 2017. — № 4. — S. 42–46.

9. Kondrat’eva S. L. Yuridicheskaya otvetstvennost’: sootnoshenie norm material’nogo i processual’nogo prava : dis. … kand. yurid. nauk. — M., 1998. — 220 s.

10. Kuplevaskij N. O. Administrativnaya yusticiya v zapadnoj Evrope. I. Administrativnaya yusticiya vo Francii //Zapiski Imperatorskogo Har’kovskogo universiteta. Har’kov. — 1881. — T. 1. — S. I–XXXII, 1–64. — URL: http://escriptorium.univer.kharkov.ua/handle/1237075002/937.

11. Nosova Yu. B. Disciplinarnaya otvetstvennost’ gosudarstvennyh grazhdanskih sluzhashchih Rossijskoj Federacii : monografiya. — Voronezh : Izd-vo Voronezh. gos. un-ta, 2011. — 208 s.

12. Panova I. V. Aktual’nye problemy administrativnogo processa v Rossijskoj Federacii : avtoref. dis. … d-ra yurid. nauk. — Ekaterinburg, 2000. — 46 s.

13. Sorokin V. D. Administrativno-processual’noe pravo : uchebnik. 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. / podg. d-rom yurid. nauk, prof. A. I. Kaplunovym. — SPb. : Izdatel’stvo R. Aslanova «Yuridicheskij centr-Press», 2008. — 569 s.

14. Teoriya yuridicheskogo processa / I. V. Benedik, V. M. Gorshenev, V. G. Krupin, Yu. I. Mel’nikov [i dr.] ; pod obshch. red. V. M. Gorsheneva. — Har’kov : Vishcha shk.; Izd-vo pri Har’k. un-te, 1985. — 192 s.

15. Yuridicheskaya processual’naya forma. Teoriya i praktika / N. V. Virtuk, V. M. Gorshenev, T. N. Dobrovol’skaya, I. A. Ikonickaya [i dr.] ; pod red. V. M. Gorsheneva, P. E. Nedbajlo. — M. : Yurid. lit., 1976. — 279 s.