Right to Self-Determination of Peoples and the Emerging World Order

In the paper, the author attempted to reveal the influence of the idea of self-determination on the emerging (in the historical and legal context) world order, taking into account the rapidly developing political and legal processes in the 18th-21st centuries. Attention is given to the use of the relevant law by certain states in their national interests, which, in the conditions of instability of the international system, makes self-determination an object of numerous influences, interpretations and restrictions. Considering cases from international practice and documents, the author concludes that over the centuries the concept of self-determination has undergone many transformations and was considered as a tool for redrawing the borders of Europe in the early and middle of the 19th century, after the end of the First World War and before the collapse of the USSR and Yugoslavia. As a mechanism of decolonization, and at the turn of the 20th–21st centuries — as a tool for fragmenting the political map of the world using the ethnic factor as a basis. Quite interesting are the conclusions about the impact of the institution of human rights, remedial secession, external and internal forms of self-determination, globalization processes on the development of the relevant law. The paper, along with other examples, examines the impact of real politics and the existence of double standards when considering issues of international legal recognition of Kosovo in the event of secession from Serbia and the annexation of Crimea to the Russian Federation.

1. Ivanyan E. A. Entsiklopediya rossiysko-amerikanskikh otnosheniy. XVIII–XX veka. — M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2001. — 696 s. — ISBN 5-7133-1045‑0.

2. Lenin V. I. O prave narodov na samoopredelenie // Polnoe sobranie sochineniy. — T. 25.

3. Lukashuk I. I. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo. Obshchaya chast. — M., 2008.

4. Annan K. Two Concepts of Sovereignty: Address to the 54th Session of the General Assembly, abgedruckt // The Question of Intervention: Statements of the Secretary-General. 2003.

5. Ansari A. M. Confronting Iran. — New York, 2009.

6. Crawford J. The Creation of States in International Law. — 2nd ed. — Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007. — 870 p. — DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199228423.001.0001.

7. Danspeckgruber W. Self-Determination in Our Time: Reflections on Perception, Globalization and Change. — 2001.

8. Ikenberry J. After victory: institutions, strategic restraint, and the rebuilding of order after major wars. — Princeton, 2010.

9. Galbraith P. W. Iraq: The Way to Go // The New York Times Book Review. — Vol. 54. — Number 13. — August 16, 2007.

10. Hobbes Th. Naturrecht und allgemeines Staatsrecht in den Anfangsgründen. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1976.

11. Kant I. Metaphysik der Sitten // Akademie Ausgabe der Gesammelten Schriften Kants. Band 6. — Munchen: Wentworth Press, 2018.

12. Locke J. Zwei Abhandlungen über die Regierung. — Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp Verlag, 1977.

13. O’Meara D. Der Mensch als politisches Lebewesen. Zum Verhältnis zwischen Platon und Aristoteles // Der Mensch — ein politisches Tier? Essays zur politischen Anthropologie, herausgegeben von Otfried Höffe. — Stuttgart, 1992. — P. 14–25.

14. Rousseau J.‑J. Vom Gesellschaftsvertrag, oder Grundsätze des Staatsrechts. Buch I. — Stuttgart: UniversalBibliothek, 1977.

15. Self-Determination and Self-Administration: A Sourcebook / W. Danspeckgruber, A. Watts (eds.). — Boulder, 1997.