Inadmissible Refusals in the Russian Civil Law
https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2019.98.1.102-110
Abstract
The paper provides systematization of inadmissible refusals in civil law enshrined in civil legislation and clarification of court practice. The author analyzes the reasons for fixing the inadmissibility of refusal through civil law cases, which include situations of protection of the weaker party in civil law relations. A specific characteristic of inadmissible refusals according to the way of their expression is proposed: with the presence or absence of legal consequences of inadmissible refusals. The “doctrine of the nullity of refusal” prevailing in modern Russian science and court practice is criticized as contradicting the fundamental principles of civil law (in particular, the principles of freedom of contract, inadmissibility of arbitrary interference in private affairs, etc.) and generally acceptable type of legal regulation peculiar to civil law. Some ways to overcome it are proposed. It is concluded that the resolution of the issue of recognizing a refusal as valid or invalid should be based on the correct qualification of the relevant norms, which fix certain legal opportunities for participants in civil law relations as imperative or dispositive.
About the Author
A. A. SuslovRussian Federation
Suslov Andrey Aleksandrovich, Postgraduate of the Department of Civil Law and Procedure
664011, Russia, Irkutsk, ul. Nekrasova, d. 4
References
1. Alekseeva E. V., Komissarova E. G., Mikshis D. V., Torkin D. A., Truba A. N. Kommentariy k Federal’nomu zakonu ot 16 iyulya 1998 g. № 102-FZ «Ob ipoteke (zaloge nedvizhimosti)» (postateyniy). — Sistema «Konsul’tantPlyus», 2016.
2. Andreev Yu. N. Sudebnaya zashchita isklyuchitel’nykh prav: tsivilisticheskie aspekty : monografiya. — M. : Norma, Infra-M, 2011.
3. Vasilevskaya L. Yu. Predotvrashchenie poter’ kreditora v natural’nom obyazatel’stve: germanskiy opyt // Prolog : zhurnal o prave. — 2016. — № 3.
4. Golovistikova A. N., Grudtsyna L. Yu., Malyshev V. A., Spektor A. A. Kommentariy k Semeynomu kodeksu Rossiyskoy Federatsii (postateyniy). — Sistema «Konsul’tantPlyus», 2008.
5. Grishaev S. P. Nasledstvennoe pravo : uchebno-prakticheskoe posobie. — M. : Prospekt, 2011.
6. Karapetov A. G., Savel’ev A. I. Svoboda dogovora i ee predely : v 2 t. — M. : Statut, 2012. — T. 1 : Teoreticheskie, istoricheskie i politiko-pravovye osnovaniya printsipa svobody dogovora i ego ogranicheniy.
7. Kratenko M. V. Zashchita prav potrebiteley uslug : spravochnik. — M. : Prospekt, 2010.
8. Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo : uchebnik : v 2 t. / pod red. S. N. Lebedeva, E. V. Kabatovoy. — M. : Statut, 2011. T. 1.
9. Mogilevskiy S. D. Obshchestvo s ogranichennoy otvetstvennost’yu: zakonodatel’stvo i praktika ego primeneniya. — M. : Statut, 2010.
10. Osipenko O. V. Aktsionernoe obshchestvo. Korporativnye protsedury. Kn. 1 : Obshchee sobranie aktsionerov i sovet direktorov. — M. : Statut, 2009.
11. Osipenko O. V. Rossiyskie kholdingi. Ekspertnye problemy formirovaniya i obespecheniya razvitiya. — M. : Statut, 2008.
12. Popova O. O. Institutsional’niy podkhod k issledovaniyu predvybornoy agitatsii // Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal’noe pravo. — 2016. — № 6.
13. Postateyniy kommentariy k Grazhdanskomu kodeksu Rossiyskoy Federatsii, chasti pervoy / pod red. P. V. Krasheninnikova. — M. : Statut, 2011.
14. Sud po intellektual’nym pravam v sisteme organov gosudarstvennoy vlasti Rossiyskoy Federatsii : monografiya / pod red. I. A. Bliznetsa, L. A. Novoselovoy. — M. : Prospekt, 2015.
15. Tarasenkova A. N. Pravovye aspekty semeynykh otnosheniy: otvety na voprosy i kommentarii // Bibliotechka «Rossiyskoy gazety». — 2014. — Vyp. 13.
16. Ushakov A. A Kommentariy k Osnovam zakonodatel’stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii o notariate (postateyniy). — 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. — M. : Delovoy dvor, 2015.
17. Cherdantsev A. F. Teoriya gosudarstva i prava : uchebnik dlya vuzov. — M. : Yurayt, 2002. — 432 s.
18. Shershenevich G. F. : uchebnik russkogo grazhdanskogo prava. Po izdaniyu 1907 g. — M. : Spark, 1995. — 556 c.
Review
For citations:
Suslov A.A. Inadmissible Refusals in the Russian Civil Law. Actual Problems of Russian Law. 2019;(1):102-110. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2019.98.1.102-110