Summary Proceedings: Issues of Assessing Indisputability of Claims

Based on the results of an analysis of the materials of judicial practice of ctate comercial (arbitrazh) courts and courts of general jurisdiction, the author highlights two law enforcement problems of summary proceedings related to the assessment of the claims as indisputable. The first is manifested in the difficulties of distinguishing the presence of a defect in documentary evidence of claims (lack of a submitted application), which is the basis for returning an application for a court order, from the existence of a dispute about the right that entails a refusal to accept this claim. Accordingly, these powers are misapplied by the courts, which affects the access to justice of interested persons, since the procedural and legal consequences of returning an application for a court order are not defined by law, and in practice there are different points of view on this matter. The second problem involves the lack of uniformity in the courts’ understanding of such a condition for the indisputability of claims as their recognition by the debtor. To solve the first problem, it is proposed to give the court the authority to leave the application motionless in summary proceedings and to achieve uniformity in the assessment by the courts of the claims as recognized by the debtor, to expand the relevant explanations of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation.

1. Bakhareva O. A. Prikaznoe proizvodstvo v sovremennom grazhdanskom protsessualnom prave RF: perspektivy razvitiya // Mirovoy sudya. - 2020. - № 9. - S. 32–35.

2. Bortnikova N. A. Uproshchennye proizvodstva v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve // SPS «KonsultantPlyus». 2019.

3. Grazhdanskiy protsess: uchebnik. - 4 e izd., pererab. i dop. / pod red. M. K. Treushnikova. - M.: Gorodets, 2011. - 832 s.

4. Grazhdanskiy protsess: uchebnik / pod red. S. V. Nikitina. - M.: RGUP, 2022. - 582 s.

5. Grazhdanskoe protsessualnoe pravo: uchebnik: v 2 t. / T. K. Andreeva, S. F. Afanasev, V. V. Blazheev [i dr.]; pod red. P. V. Krasheninnikova. T. 1: Obshchaya chast. - 2 e izd., pererab. i dop. - M.: Statut, 2022. - 550 s.

6. Zhilin G. A. Pravosudie po grazhdanskim delam: aktualnye voprosy: monografiya. - M.: Prospekt, 2010. - 576 s.

7. Kovtkov D. I. Prikaznoe proizvodstvo: pravovoe regulirovanie, problemy, perspektivy razvitiya // Mirovoy sudya. - 2010. - № 12. - S. 6-12.

8. Kolesnikov S. G. Problemnye voprosy v deyatelnosti arbitrazhnykh sudov v svyazi s vvedeniem prikaznogo proizvodstva // Vestnik Pskovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya «Ekonomika. Pravo. Upravlenie». - 2016. - № 4. - S. 133-139.

9. Komarova T. A. Ob aktualnykh problemakh, voznikayushchikh pri podache iskovogo zayavleniya, zayavleniya o vynesenii sudebnogo prikaza // Sovremennye tendentsii razvitiya grazhdanskogo i grazhdanskogo protsessualnogo zakonodatelstva i praktiki ego primeneniya. - 2020. - № 6. - S. 202-207.

10. Kommentariy k Grazhdanskomu protsessualnomu kodeksu Rossiyskoy Federatsii / pod red. M. A. Vikut. - M., 2003. - 607 s.

11. Kommentariy k Grazhdanskomu protsessualnomu kodeksu Rossiyskoy Federatsii (postateynyy) / D. B. Abushenko, A. M. Grebentsov, S. L. Degtyarev [i dr.]; pod obshch. red. V. I. Nechaeva. - 3 e izd., pererab. i dop. - M.: Norma, 2008. - 976 s.

12. Krasheninnikov P. V., Ruzakova O. A., Slavinskaya G. A. Kommentariy k Grazhdanskomu protsessualnomu kodeksu Rossiyskoy Federatsii // Vestnik grazhdanskogo protsessa. - 2014. - № 1. - S. 85-117.

13. Mamedova M. K. Protsessualnye osobennosti rassmotreniya del o vzyskanii alimentov: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk. - M., 2000. - 35 s.

14. Markin S. V. O sovershenstvovanii prikaznogo proizvodstva // Nauka i obrazovanie: khozyaystvo i ekonomika; predprinimatelstvo; pravo i upravlenie. - 2016. № 2 (69). - S. 139-142.

15. Nikitin S. V. Nekotorye voprosy prikaznogo proizvodstva // Arbitrazhnyy i grazhdanskiy protsess. - 2008. - № 7.

16. Osokina G. L. Grazhdanskiy protsess. Osobennaya chast. - M.: Norma, 2010. - 960 s.

17. Savenko A. D. Aktualnye problemy vyneseniya sudebnogo prikaza v arbitrazhnom protsesse // Fundamentalnye i prikladnye aspekty razvitiya sovremennoy nauki: sbornik statey po materialam Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoprakticheskoy konferentsii, Ufa, 18 dekabrya 2019 g. Ch. 2. - Ufa: Vestnik nauki, 2019. - S. 51-55.

18. Khasanshina F. G. Vozbuzhdenie proizvodstva po delu v arbitrazhnom sude: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk: 12.00.15. - Saratov, 2012. - 27 s.

19. Cheremin M. A. Prikaznoe proizvodstvo v rossiyskom grazhdanskom protsesse: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk: 12.00.03. - M., 1999. - 28 s.

20. Yadrentsev V. F. Reformirovanie prikaznogo proizvodstva v grazhdanskom protsesse // Novaya nauka: Sovremennoe sostoyanie i puti razvitiya. - 2016. - № 4 3. - S. 228-230.