Legal Aspect of the Clergy Privilege: Comparative Analysis of Legislative Bases and Problems
https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2025.172.3.189-198
Abstract
The paper addresses one of the most controversial privileges in the legal field — the clergy privilege. Despite on-and-off attempts to level out the «seal of secrecy», it is enshrined in the laws of most countries as a guarantee of freedom of religion. The presence of specific features allows it to be considered as a separate type of privilege. A comparative legal analysis of the legal regulation of this type of secret in Russian law and the law of foreign countries is carried out. Despite terminological differences, the clergy privilege is protected through the witness immunity of clergy in the procedural sphere. The result of the study was the identification of problem areas in the legal regulation of the clergy privilege, and the formation of a number of proposals for the transformation of Russian legislation in this area.
About the Author
A. V. Sidorova
Samara State University of Economics
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Anna V. Sidorova, Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Associate Professor, Department of Economic Crimes Enforcement
Samara
References
1. Andreev K. M. Osobennosti tayny pri realizatsii konstitutsionnoy svobody veroispovedaniya (rossiyskiy i zarubezhnyy opyt): avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk. — M., 2015. — 27 s.
2. Andreev K. M. Ponyatie i osobennosti religioznoy tayny v ramkakh realizatsii konstitutsionnoy svobody veroispovedaniya: monografiya. — M.: Yurisprudentsiya, 2015. — 227 s.
3. Andreev K. M. Pravo na religioznuyu taynu v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: monografiya. — M.: Yurisprudentsiya, 2014. — 180 s.
4. Kodeks kanonicheskogo prava. — M.: In-t filosofii, teologii i istorii sv. Fomy, 2007. — 620 s.
5. Kollantay V. A. (svyashch.) O napravleniyakh realizatsii pravovogo immuniteta svyashchennosluzhitelya russkoy pravoslavnoy tserkvi v operativno-rozysknoy deyatelnosti // Filosofiya prava. — 2022. — № 2 (101). — S. 66–74.
6. Monastyrskiy khronograf. Dukhovnyy reglament Petra I 1721 goda // URL: https://monasterium.by/ustavy_i_dokumenty/dokumenty/dukhovnyy-reglament-petra-i-1721-ujl/ (data obrashcheniya: 10.05.2024).
7. Nomokanon pri bolshom trebnike: Ego istoriya i teksty, grech. i slav., s obyasn. i kritich. primech.: Opyt nauch. razresheniya vopr. ob etom sb., voznikavshikh v proshlom stoletii v Svyateyshem pravitelstvuyushchem sinode. — M.: Tip. G. Lissnera i A. Geshelya, preemn. E. Lissnera i Yu. Romana, 1897.
8. Pchelintsev A. V. Svoboda veroispovedaniya i religioznye obedineniya v Rossiyskoy Federatsii (konstitutsionnopravovoe issledovanie): avtoref. dis. … d-ra yurid. nauk. — M., 2012. — 57 s.
9. Pchelintsev A. V., Andreev K. M. Religioznaya tayna. — M.: Yurisprudentsiya, 2014. — 63 s.
10. Rossiyskoe zakonodatelstvo X–XX vekov. T. 6. — M., 1988. — 432 s.
11. Smolkova I. V. Problemy, okhranyaemoy zakonom tayny v ugolovnom protsesse: dis. … d-ra yurid. nauk. — Irkutsk, 1998. — 404 s.
12. Tatyanin D., Zakirova L. Problemy tayny ispovedi v ugolovnom protsesse Rossii // Vestnik OGU. — 2011. — № 3 (122). — S. 140–142.
13. Khoynatskiy A. Prakticheskoe rukovodstvo dlya svyashchennosluzhiteley pri sovershenii tserkovnykh treb v 4 vypuskakh. Vyp. 2-y. O Tainstve Ispovedi. 1873 // URL: https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/Andrej_Hojnackij/prakticheskoe-rukovodstvo-dlja-svjashhennosluzhitelej-pri-sovershenii-tserkovnyh-treb-v-4-vypuskah/2 (data obrashcheniya: 10.05.2024).
14. Shibaev D. V. Pravovoy rezhim tayny ispovedi. Sootnoshenie svetskogo i kanonicheskogo prava // Russian journal of legal studies. — 2017. — № 3 (12). — S. 71–79.
15. Shchur A. S. Tayna ispovedi v usloviyakh razvitiya tsifrovykh tekhnologiy // Pravovoe regulirovanie otnosheniy, voznikayushchikh v svyazi s razvitiem tsifrovoy ekonomiki: sbornik statey mezhvuzovskogo kruglogo stola s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem, Minsk, 27 oktyabrya 2022 g. — Minsk: BGEU, 2022. — S. 164–167.
16. Guidelines for the Professional Conduct of the Clergy. — The Convocations of Canterbury and York, 2014.
Review
For citations:
Sidorova A.V. Legal Aspect of the Clergy Privilege: Comparative Analysis of Legislative Bases and Problems. Actual Problems of Russian Law. 2025;20(3):189-198. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17803/1994-1471.2025.172.3.189-198
Views:
99
Email this article 